Friday, April 9, 2010

Thiele Should Look In Mirror, Not Blame Others About Stony Brook Southampton Closing

Sad news this week as Stony Brook University announced that they would be reducing service to their Southampton Campus, effectively ending student residences on campus and destroying the fragile community that faculty, students and administrators have worked so hard to build over the past three years. I know of what I speak firsthand as Southampton hired me for my first real teaching gig, teaching a class called “Environmental Problems and Solutions” in the Spring of 2008. There has been a lot of coverage of the issue via the New York Times, 27east.com and the Sag Harbor Times.

Unfortunately this is a story that is repeating itself over and over again over the entire country as the economy suffers. State and local officials grappling with tough decisions about which worthwhile and valuable services to cut, to avoid crippling budget deficits and states and municipalities going bankrupt. The only problem is, in this case that this campus closure is not forced by a crumbling economy, but by extremely poor government policy in Albany.

The State University of New York (SUNY) is one of a very few institutions of higher learning in the United States to have their tuition set not by the University Trustees or Administrators but rather by a legislative body. Traditionally every 5 or so years when the state legislature bothers to think about it, lawmakers review tuition and vote to increase it as a function of inflation or other economic pressures. This occurred last year during the academic year, the legislature voted to increase tuition midway through the year. This caused students who had budgeted for tuition some duress – but this was not the real crime of the bill. Instead the real crime of the bill was that the increase in tuition did NOT go to the SUNY system, but instead went to the state’s general fund. Students were not paying for education, they were paying to cover other expenses the state had incurred.

Let me say this again. The legislature increased tuition to pay for other programs. The legislature taxed students to pay for their pork. Why? Because lawmakers are terrified to increase taxes to pay for the programs they fund. Instead they increase fees at state agencies (e.g. vehicle registration, recreational fishing permits) and pocket the money to pay for other projects. Brilliant!

So SUNY came up with a plan that they hope to convince lawmakers and the governor of. Allow SUNY trustees to set tuition and keep the tuition inside of SUNY for distribution. Some campuses could have a higher tuition, and some campuses could have a lower tuition based on what services they provide and the level of education granted. What do lawmakers like State Assemblyman Fred Thiele think of this plan?


The second problem is that the campus is caught in what Thiele called “Albany politics.”

The state university system, he said, wants to offer different tuition rates at different schools, and it wants to set those rates without any oversight.

“The legislature is leery of that,” said Thiele.


Of course the legislature is leery of that! How else will they continue to pass along their increased spending to taxpayers without actually doing the politically unpopular, but responsible action of raising taxes. Responsibility, that is something the legislature is truly leery of. Instead they just pass the expense onto college students.

The closure of Southampton Campus is expected to save Stony Brook $6 million annually. If SUNY had been able to use the funds generated by increasing tuition, would this closure be necessary? Enrollment at Southampton is up – way up – perhaps with the funds from the tuition increase the State could have kept Southampton open long enough to build up a program that could break even. Instead $55 million that has been spent improving the campus is going to waste.

So Fred Thiele, instead of blaming others, take action. Vote to keep all tuition money paid by students in the SUNY system. Then vote to make sure in the future lawmakers can’t steal from the SUNY cookie jar again, allow trustees to set tuition levels. Lastly, take responsibility to the fact that it is policy enacted under your watch that caused Southampton to be closed. Don’t pass the buck.

6 comments:

Koch Family said...

Nicely stated Owen....

Unknown said...

Lindsay and I were talking about this last night...we agree 100%...this is the sad consequence of our legislators inability to take responsibility for their actions and try hide behind cleaver schemes...which often fail. Man...Southampton really had potential.

linda said...

The only comment I had heard about its closure was that it was costing a million dollars a year for 400-500 students. But this helps shed some additional light on the situation, so thank you.

Karen said...

I am so pleased to finally see the truth in "print" -- or at least online! (And well stated.) Whenever I mention to anyone what happened to the last tuition increase they are shocked. I don't understand why the new media has not been reporting this.

While it's tough paying college tuition anywhere in these economic times (I have two kids in college myself) the tuition at SBU is set too low to support the quality of the institution. The out-of-state tuition, for example, is lower than the in-state tuition in Pennsylvania. The tuition at all SUNY schools is equal, even though the cost of education is not. And then the state KEEPS most of the money from the tuition increase. Totally outrageous.

Thank you, Owen, for your post. I encourage readers to forward it -- especially to those who pay tuition and vote.

Maggleton said...

The SUNY increase is still more affordable than the UC increase. 16% increase at the beginning of winter 2010 and another 16% at the beginning of fall 2010. This in conjunction with furlough days, reduced course offerings, fewer TA appointments, and increased costs across campus.

Carlos said...

There is a petition now going to the White House with support from Green Party presidential candidate ('08) Cynthia McKinney to make hemp legal in the US -
gotta get 25,000 signatures - so please make your vote count here -
www.minawear/about-us/
you can also leave a comment on that site!
For more info also check out www.hempforvictory.blogspot.com